Journal

book inc  –  journal  –  Ask Tina: From Down Draft to Dental Draft
Ask Tina_ From Down Draft to Dental Draft

Ask Tina: From Down Draft to Dental Draft

Ask Tina helps a writer facing a daunting second draft with realistic expectations and practical strategies, from reading aloud and gathering targeted feedback to revising in rounds and reverse outlining.

Tina Goodyear

November 05, 2026

Dear Tina,

While writing, I really embraced the “shitty first draft” mantra, and it helped me get words on the page, but now the process of molding that first draft into a good book feels daunting. Do you have any tips for revision, perhaps for managing my expectations around the revision process? 

Signed,

Second Drafter


Dear Second Drafter,

While I’m a champion of setting high expectations, I’m also a realist, so here’s my attempt at managing your revision expectations: Expect it to be challenging and non-linear. I promise you will not be disappointed. At times, your muse will perch on your shoulder, laughing gleefully as you delete whole paragraphs; other days she will be missing-in-action and every page will feel like a battleground. 

Project Write Now’s very own Jen Gaites knows your pain. She compares a first draft to her son’s messy bedroom and offers some practical advice in Facing the Mess of Revision. 

She also cites Anne Lamont of “shitty first draft” fame. Turns out Lamont didn’t leave us hanging after the first draft, which she dubbed the “down draft.” She moves on to the “up draft” and the “dental draft.” Those who’ve had a root canal need no explanation for that last one. 

Seems like you’re in the “up draft” phase, although I would argue that you will end up with more drafts than even Ann Lamont can name, certainly more than three! But naming them doesn’t make revision any easier to tackle. Here are some practical suggestions.

1. Before you start making any changes, take the advice of Elizabeth Jannuzzi, author of Sober Mom (and editor of the book inc journal): read it out loud. Every word! Some writers save this read aloud for the dental or final draft to catch typos, awkward phrasing and other mishaps, but I think it’s a great way to start the revision party.

2. After a readthrough and some minor adjustments, share it with a trusted reader, but be sure to ask for specific feedback on overall plot, structure, or characters. See last month’s column for more about posing questions. Better yet, consider joining a revision workshop, such as the book inc Book Revision Lab. You will be guided through a structured approach to revision with a cadre of ready readers. 

3. Armed with some good feedback, consider working through a multi-step process rather than trying to tackle everything at once. For example:

  • First round – read for plot and structure: Does the plot make sense? Does each scene or chapter move the story forward? Have you hit all of the beats?
  • Second round – read for characters and dialogue: Does each character have a distinct voice? Do their actions align and help move the plot along?  
  • Third round – start to edit and polish: grammar, verb usage, punctuation.

4. Try a reverse outline approach. Remember when your tenth-grade English teacher forced you to make an outline of your research paper before you started writing? Little did she know, you can do this AFTER you write a first draft. Reverse outlining involves going through your draft scene by scene, paragraph by paragraph, chapter by chapter, and answering a series of questions pertaining to character, plot, narrative. I struggle with it…all that detail when I could just be writing! – but other writers swear by it. 

Finally, I’d like to add some joy to your expectations. Expect to feel really good at times in the revision process. It’s not unlike birthing and raising a child or applying to and completing a PhD program. When you look at the process as a whole, the good outweighs the struggle. 

So, since Anne Lamont started this whole thing with her “shitty first draft” theory, let’s give her the last word:  

“I heard a preacher say recently that hope is a revolutionary patience; let me add that so is being a writer. Hope begins in the dark, the stubborn hope that if you just show up and try to do the right thing, the dawn will come. You wait and watch and work: you don’t give up.” ― Anne Lamott, Bird by Bird

Do you have a writing-related dilemma? Send your questions to asktina@projectwritenow.org. Selected questions will be featured in upcoming columns, and Tina will ensure her answers offer valuable insights for writers facing similar challenges.

Reference: Lamott, Anne. Bird by Bird: Some Instructions on Writing and Life. Anchor Books, 1995.

Tina Goodyear
Tina Goodyear

<a href="https://bookinc.org/member/tgoodyear/" rel="noopener">Tina Goodyear</a> is a board member of <a href="https://projectwritenow.org/" rel="noopener">Project Write Now</a> and a <a href="https://bookinc.org/" rel="noopener">book inc</a> Peer Artist Leader. She recently completed a draft of her memoir, FROM THE NECK DOWN. When not writing or teaching the art of writing, she helps adult students earn college credit for their work and life experiences.

Tina Goodyear is a board member of Project Write Now and a book inc Peer Artist Leader. She recently completed a draft of her memoir, FROM THE NECK DOWN. When not writing or teaching the art of writing, she helps adult students earn college credit for their work and life experiences.